All resources

Review 10 min read

Is ChatGPT replacing Google search? Why I'd treat it as a second channel, not a swap

OpenAI's "one-fifth of Google" claim is a real signal but a weak benchmark. Keep your SEO foundations and start measuring AI answers as a separate channel.

No, I don't think ChatGPT is replacing Google search. But it is now a discovery channel big enough that you need to measure it separately, not through your Google numbers. Taking money out of SEO to chase it is the wrong move. Keep the foundations that feed both channels, and add the things SEO doesn't give you.

Is ChatGPT replacing Google search? What the 20% figure actually measures

On 2 November 2026, Adam Fry, who leads ChatGPT's consumer product, told Alex Kantrowitz that "ChatGPT's volume of search-like queries is now roughly one-fifth the volume of queries of Google" (Big Technology). The headline spread quickly. I think the number is a real signal. I would not build a budget on it.

What does OpenAI count as a search?

Fry defined search-like use as "basically anything that a user would have traditionally gone to a traditional search engine for." Forbes and PPC Land report that OpenAI counts any prompt that sends ChatGPT to the web for an answer. That includes questions nobody would have typed into a search box a few years ago. The part of the interview that explains how searches are counted is behind a paywall, so the exact method is not public.

The missing Google baseline

Fry did not say where the Google figure came from. 9to5Google wrote that its source "wasn't revealed." 24/7 Wall St. noted that no time period or region was given either. OpenAI is a private company, so nobody can check the figure independently.

What do independent estimates say?

EstimateFigureWhat it compares
OpenAI, November 2026About 20% of GooglePrompts that trigger a web search (as reported) against an undisclosed Google figure
Ahrefs, February 2026About 12%ChatGPT prompts treated as search-equivalent against Google's traditional search volume
seoClarity7.5%Independent estimate of ChatGPT's search volume against Google's
Ahrefs, referral trafficAbout 190×How much more traffic Google sends to websites than ChatGPT does

The Ahrefs and seoClarity figures come from 24/7 Wall St.'s reporting. Google also says its own search volume is at an all-time high. As Barry Schwartz pointed out, a fifth of a growing number does not prove that Google is shrinking.

Still, don't dismiss it. The Verge, summarized by Slashdot, recalled that Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella said in 2023 that Bing had about 3% of search after more than a decade. That is a market share, not a ratio to Google, so the numbers don't compare directly. But even the lowest independent estimate says ChatGPT is not a niche tool. More and more customers ask an assistant the questions they used to type into Google, and most business owners have no idea what the assistant answers. That is why I call it a second channel.

Is Google traffic already running through AI?

The "swap" question assumes Google stays the same. It doesn't. AI Overviews are AI-written summaries at the top of Google results. AI Mode is Google's chat-style search. Both answer more questions on the results page, so people click through less.

Digiday spoke to 18 media buyers. They said clients no longer treat Google search spend as automatic, and that 10–30% of search budgets now get extra scrutiny (via PPC Land). Search still took $114.2B of US digital ad spend last year, according to IAB/PwC. PPC Land also reported that on 2 November Google quietly moved AI Overviews for brand searches into the right-hand column, in the US results it checked. According to the same report, Ahrefs found AI Overviews on 63 of 100 brand names by 30 September, up from 5 of 98 on 1 July.

Google's own numbers show the same tension. Alphabet's Search & other revenue was $63.35B in Q3 2026, up 12% year over year (Yahoo Finance). According to Tech Insider's report on the earnings call, Google said AI Mode queries currently earn less money than classic Search queries. My conclusion: "Google traffic" is no longer one thing. Part of what you call SEO is already AI visibility, inside Google.

The sources AI reads are moving

On its Q3 2026 earnings call, Reddit said it is moving to a "primarily logged-in experience." It also said search referrals fell by more than 1 million a week on average in October (TechCrunch). According to Reuters, CEO Steve Huffman linked the plan to Google's AI search features and to stopping data scraping. "The AI mode does not drive traffic, not for us and not to anybody," he said. Tests start in Q4 2026 in select markets outside the US.

Why does this matter to you? Assistants build answers from forums, reviews, directories and company sites. When a major source limits access, what assistants can read and quote changes too. The effect on AI answers is not clear yet. Reddit says it will keep some access for search visitors and first-time users (summary of its shareholder letter), and there is no evidence that AI engines will stop citing it. My lesson is simpler: don't rely on third parties to describe your business. State your facts clearly on your own site.

Should you cut SEO to chase ChatGPT?

No. The same foundations feed both channels: pages that crawlers can reach, clear facts, and structured data. Structured data is code that labels prices, hours and addresses so machines read them reliably. Google says there are no extra requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode beyond normal Search eligibility. The Verge reports that OpenAI likely relies on Bing for a large part of ChatGPT's searches (via Slashdot). A site that search engines can't read well is weak in AI answers too.

The traffic data points the same way. Google still sends far more visitors to websites than ChatGPT does. A Semrush study found no statistically significant change in daily Google sessions after people started using ChatGPT. That supports "expansion," not "substitution": people add AI to their search habits rather than drop Google. GEO, or generative engine optimization, is the work of getting your business named in AI answers. I go through the longer story in our research on how visibility rules are changing from SEO to GEO.

But AI bots read a site differently from Google and from people. They need clear, specific facts about your business. A page can rank well and still give an assistant no clear answer to "how much does it cost?" or "are they open on Sunday?" So add to SEO. Don't replace it.

How do you measure AI visibility on its own terms?

AI answers are not rankings. There is no position one, and the same question can get a different answer tomorrow. What you measure is how often assistants name you, and whether what they say is correct. We call this share of model: the share of relevant AI answers that mention your business. The method is in our research on measuring share of model.

Measure before and after every change. That is the only honest way to know if something worked. Sereda.ai, a Ukrainian HR platform, is the one case I can point to. Before it had an AI Page (one page with the business facts for AI assistants), ChatGPT said it did not know the product. The AI Page went live on 22 October 2025. Two researchers scored the answers independently on 5 criteria, 10 points each, scaled to 100 and averaged over 4 questions. ChatGPT went from 24 to 87 and Gemini from 28 to 91 (before: September to early October 2025; after: early December 2025). That is one result, not a promise.

At Chetver we built Pulse for the technical side of this. It shows which AI bots visit your site, what they read and where they hit errors. On the Max plan, we also ask ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity and Gemini your test questions every week and count how many answers mention you. You can also do a simple version by hand, as described below.

AI bot requests on a demo site: which ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity bots visited and what they read. Your server logs hold the same information, but unsorted.
AI bot requests on a demo site: which ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity bots visited and what they read. Your server logs hold the same information, but unsorted. (Chetver dashboard on a demo site)

When should you rethink the budget split?

Move money because of your own data, not because of headlines. These signals are worth acting on:

  • Your share of mentions on your test questions, tracked over several weeks.
  • Referral visits from chatgpt.com, perplexity.ai and gemini.google.com in your analytics, and whether those visits convert.
  • In Google Search Console, falling clicks with steady impressions. Then check by hand whether those queries now show an AI Overview.

Even then, I would fund AI visibility from your testing budget, not from SEO basics. For example, imagine a local law firm whose Google clicks drop on "how much does a divorce lawyer cost" questions. Before cutting anything, I would check what AI Overviews and ChatGPT say about its fees, and whether its own site states them clearly.

What I would do in your place

  1. Write 5–10 test questions a customer would actually ask. For example, imagine a dental clinic: "Which clinic near downtown does same-day crowns, and what does it cost?" Ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity by hand. Note whether they name you and whether your prices, hours and address are correct.
  2. Check your robots.txt. This file tells crawlers what they may read. Make sure it doesn't block the bots below by accident. Also ask whoever runs your hosting, firewall or CDN whether they block AI bots by default. If you publish an llms.txt file, a proposed file that points AI tools to your key pages, check that it is current. Our research on llms.txt and other AI-crawler signals explains what each signal does.
  3. Look at your server logs. Search for AI bot names, for example grep -E "OAI-SearchBot|ChatGPT-User|GPTBot|PerplexityBot|Perplexity-User" access.log. Look for 4xx and 5xx responses: error codes such as 403 (forbidden, often a firewall block), 404 (page not found) or 503 (server unavailable). A bot that gets an error or a block page does not learn your facts.
  4. Keep your business facts in one clean place. Put prices, opening hours, contacts and services on a single crawlable page in plain HTML, not inside images or scripts. Make it match what your Google Business Profile and directories say.
BotOwnerWhat it does
OAI-SearchBotOpenAIFinds sites and shows them in ChatGPT search results
ChatGPT-UserOpenAIFetches a page when a ChatGPT user's request needs it
GPTBotOpenAICollects content for model training; blocking it is a separate choice from ChatGPT search
PerplexityBotPerplexityIndexes sites and links to them in Perplexity answers
Perplexity-UserPerplexityFetches a page when a Perplexity user's request needs it
GooglebotGoogleCrawls for Search, which includes AI Overviews and AI Mode

ChatGPT is a second channel, not a replacement. Keep the first one strong and start measuring the second. If you want a quick starting point, our free AI check shows how assistants see your business today and what to fix first.

Frequently asked questions

Is ChatGPT replacing Google search?

Not according to the data so far. Google says its search volume is at an all-time high, and a 2025 Semrush study found that Google use did not change significantly after people started using ChatGPT. But ChatGPT is now big enough to count as a separate discovery channel, so it is worth measuring on its own.

How much search does ChatGPT handle compared to Google?

OpenAI says ChatGPT's search-like queries are roughly one-fifth of Google's. As reported, it counts prompts that trigger a web search, and it did not say where its Google figure comes from. Independent estimates are lower: about 12% from Ahrefs and 7.5% from seoClarity.

Should I stop investing in SEO and focus on ChatGPT instead?

No. Crawlable pages, clear facts and structured data help you in Google and in AI assistants alike, and Google still sends far more traffic to websites. Keep SEO, and add a separate check of what AI assistants say about you.

If I block GPTBot, will my site disappear from ChatGPT search?

No. OpenAI runs separate bots. GPTBot collects content for training, while OAI-SearchBot surfaces sites in ChatGPT search, and you can allow or block each one in robots.txt. Check OpenAI's current crawler documentation before you change anything.

How do I find out if ChatGPT recommends my business?

Write 5–10 questions your customers would actually ask, put them to ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity, and note whether you are named and whether the facts are right. Repeat on a schedule, because answers change over time.

llms.txt and an AI Page for your site, written by us.

Basic

$29/ mo per site

or $290 a year, 2 months free

  • An AI Page and a file for AI bots, refreshed monthly
  • A weekly website check and a list of fixes
  • A summary of AI bot requests

30-day money-back guarantee · cancel anytime